Advisor / Run it / Comparison

Payroll services compared

Seven payroll services for small businesses, ranked on what a five-person team pays each month and how clear the pricing is. We have not run payroll on them.

By the Arorix team. . Prices as reported by published third-party reviews in November 2026. We have not bought or tested these products. Check each company's site for the current price. General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

None of the services on this page pays Arorix. If that changes, the card will say "Partner link". The order follows our price score, and ties are listed alphabetically. See how we score.

The short answer

Patriot Payroll and Square Payroll tie for the highest price score in this comparison, 9.0 out of 10. Gusto and OnPay are next at 8.0. ADP RUN and Paychex Flex share the lowest score, 3.3. The score covers price and how clear the pricing is, from prices reported by third-party reviews in November 2026. It does not measure features or quality.

At a glance

ServiceScoreBase feePer person
Patriot Payroll9.0$37 full service$5
Square Payroll9.0$35$6
Gusto8.0$49$6
OnPay8.0$49$6
QuickBooks Payroll7.0$50$7
ADP RUN3.3QuoteQuote
Paychex Flex3.3QuoteQuote

From Arorix. Not ranked.

Arorix OS

Arorix OS tracks team time for crews. It does not run payroll, so you still need one of the services below. It is our own product, so we do not score it or rank it against the others. No public price yet.

See Arorix OS

Tied number 1 of 7

Patriot Payroll

Low-cost payroll with a do-it-yourself plan and a full-service plan.

What we like

  • Full service reported at $37 a month plus $5 per worker
  • A $17 Basic plan if you file the taxes yourself

What we don't like

  • The $17 plan leaves the tax filings to you
  • Reviewers call the interface plain

9.0Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 1 of 7

Square Payroll

Payroll from Square, often used with Square POS.

What we like

  • Reported at $35 a month plus $6 per person
  • Multi-state payroll included

What we don't like

  • HR tools mostly come as add-ons
  • Best fit if you already use Square

9.0Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 3 of 7

Gusto

Payroll with HR and benefits in the same account.

What we like

  • Payroll, HR and benefits in one place
  • Published prices, reported at $49 plus $6 per person

What we don't like

  • Reviewers note a recent price increase
  • Multi-state payroll needs the Plus plan
  • Common complaint: longer waits for phone support, and a price that climbs as you add features

8.0Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 3 of 7

OnPay

Single-plan payroll with HR tools included.

What we like

  • One plan with multi-state payroll included
  • Published price, reported at $49 plus $6 per person

What we don't like

  • One plan, so little room to tailor
  • Fewer integrations than larger providers

8.0Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Number 5 of 7

QuickBooks Payroll

Payroll from Intuit that ties into QuickBooks Online.

What we like

  • Ties straight into QuickBooks Online
  • Next-day direct deposit

What we don't like

  • Reviewers report frequent price changes
  • Higher base and per-person fees than most here
  • Common complaint: frequent price increases. Per-employee fees went up again in July 2026

7.0Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 6 of 7

ADP RUN

Small-business payroll from ADP.

What we like

  • Suits businesses planning to grow past 50 employees
  • Dedicated support

What we don't like

  • No published price, you need a quote
  • Add-ons are priced separately
  • Common complaint: upselling, rigid contracts, and setup and per-payroll fees on top of the quote

3.3Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 6 of 7

Paychex Flex

Payroll and HR from Paychex.

What we like

  • A dedicated payroll specialist
  • HR and retirement benefits available

What we don't like

  • No published price, you need a quote
  • Three tiers with no list prices to compare
  • Common complaint: upselling, rigid contracts, and setup and per-payroll fees on top of the quote

3.3Price score out of 10, from 3 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

What does a payroll service do?

It calculates each paycheck, pays your people, and with a full-service plan files and pays the payroll taxes for you.

Mistakes to avoid

Choosing a plan that does not file taxes

The cheapest plans can leave the tax filings to you.

Forgetting the per-person fee

The base fee is only part of the bill. Multiply the per-person fee by your headcount.

Missing multi-state costs

Paying people in more than one state can need a higher plan.

Common questions

Which one has the best price score?

Patriot Payroll and Square Payroll tie at 9.0 out of 10, the highest in this comparison. The score is built from: five-person cost; base fee; clarity.

Did Arorix test these products?

No. We have not bought or tested them. Prices come from published third-party reviews in November 2026, and the score covers price and pricing clarity only. Check each company's own site for the current price before you buy.

Does Arorix get paid by any of these companies?

None of the services on this page pays Arorix. If that changes, the card will say "Partner link".

More comparisons in Run it

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Back to Run it

See the stage