Advisor / Start / Comparison

Business insurance compared

Six places to buy small-business insurance, ranked on average general liability cost in one published study and on how easy it is to buy online. Your own price will differ. We have not bought policies from them.

By the Arorix team. . Prices as reported by published third-party reviews in November 2026. We have not bought or tested these products. Check each company's site for the current price. General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

None of the services on this page pays Arorix. If that changes, the card will say "Partner link". The order follows our price score, and ties are listed alphabetically. See how we score.

The short answer

ERGO NEXT has the highest price score in this comparison, 9.0 out of 10 (average general liability cost: $107 a month; buy online: Yes). biBERK and Thimble are next at 8.5. Hiscox scores lowest at 7.5. The score covers price and how clear the pricing is, from prices reported by third-party reviews in November 2026. It does not measure features or quality.

At a glance

ServiceScoreAverage general liability costBuy online
ERGO NEXT9.0$107 a monthYes
biBERK8.5$114 a monthYes
Thimble8.5$115 a monthYes
Simply Business8.0$119 a monthYes
The Hartford8.0$102 a monthUnder $1M revenue only
Hiscox7.5Not reportedYes

Number 1 of 6

ERGO NEXT

Online insurer for small businesses, formerly Next Insurance.

What we like

  • Quote, buy and get a certificate online
  • Among the lowest average prices in the study

What we don't like

  • Reviews note more complaints than its size would suggest
  • Your price depends on your trade
  • Common complaint: NerdWallet reports far more complaints to state regulators than expected for its size. It does not say what they were about

9.0Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 2 of 6

biBERK

Direct small-business insurer owned by Berkshire Hathaway.

What we like

  • Buy direct from the insurer online
  • Low prices for sole proprietors with simple businesses

What we don't like

  • More complex or higher-risk businesses may not qualify
  • Reviews note more complaints than its size would suggest
  • Common complaint: NerdWallet reports far more complaints to state regulators than expected for its size. It does not say what they were about

8.5Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 2 of 6

Thimble

Insurer offering monthly and short-term policies.

What we like

  • Flexible terms, including short-term cover
  • Instant certificate of insurance

What we don't like

  • No commercial auto policies
  • Adding professional liability roughly doubles the price
  • Common complaint: support and billing problems after the sale. Its Trustpilot score was reported at 1.5 from 25 reviews

8.5Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 4 of 6

Simply Business

Online broker that shows quotes from several insurers.

What we like

  • Compare several insurers in one application
  • Quote and buy online

What we don't like

  • A broker, not the insurer that pays the claim
  • Highest average price in the study

8.0Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Tied number 4 of 6

The Hartford

Long-established insurer with an agent network.

What we like

  • Lowest average general liability price in the study
  • Rated well for claims in the same study

What we don't like

  • Online quotes only for businesses under $1 million in revenue
  • Often sold through agents

8.0Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

Number 6 of 6

Hiscox

Insurer focused on small businesses and professionals.

What we like

  • Specializes in small-business policies
  • Policies can be tailored

What we don't like

  • No average price in the study we used
  • Reviews note more complaints than its size would suggest
  • Common complaint: NerdWallet reports more complaints to state regulators than expected for its size. It does not say what they were about

7.5Price score out of 10, from 2 marks

Read the review No partner link. Arorix earns nothing from this one.

What is general liability insurance?

It covers claims that your business injured someone or damaged their property. It is usually the first policy a small business buys. It does not cover injuries to your own employees, which is what workers' compensation is for.

Mistakes to avoid

Comparing on one quote

Prices depend on your trade, state and payroll. Get at least three quotes.

Calling yourself licensed when you are insured

They are different things. Say what you hold.

Letting the certificate lapse

Customers and landlords may ask for a current certificate of insurance.

Common questions

Which one has the best price score?

ERGO NEXT scores 9.0 out of 10, the highest in this comparison. The score is built from: average cost; buying online.

Did Arorix test these products?

No. We have not bought or tested them. Prices come from published third-party reviews in November 2026, and the score covers price and pricing clarity only. Check each company's own site for the current price before you buy.

Does Arorix get paid by any of these companies?

None of the services on this page pays Arorix. If that changes, the card will say "Partner link".

More comparisons in Start

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Back to Start

See the stage